Wednesday, 30 March 2011

Presentation of evaluation

Friday, 18 March 2011

Evaluation

Feedback

As well as giving my questionaires out I decided to post a link on my facebook page to my music video and a template of the questionaire in the hope that some people may fill it in. Facebook would not let me post my questionaire in the form of a post as it took up too many characters so I had to paste it into a note form post. By posting it onto Facebook I could broadcast it to a wider audience of 716 friends I have previously added on the social networking site. The high levels of technology allow me to converge the two types of media into the form of read only media and web 2.0 with the opportunity of commenting on the post. Unfortunately nobody replied with the questionaire, presumably because it was so time consuming and impracticle however I did recieve a few comments and advice on the music video which was a great source of feedback. In the future i will look into recieving feedback in other forms of media. (Click image to enlarge)

Audience Feedback


This is the questionaire we gave to our audience to get some feedback for our music video. We gave them out to 20 students from our college and 20 people outside of college to get a variety of audience responses. We used 12 questions with quantitative data and answers to chose from and qualitative data that the participant has wrote either through a comment or response to a question with advice, opinions and negative points. To analyse our results I created graphs showing me my results and the comments people have left me.

1. What age category are you in?

under 16- 2

16-18- 25

19-24- 7

25-30- 5

30+ - 1



2. Do you think our music video follows the forms and conventions of typical pop music videos?

Yes- 37
No- 40





3. In what way do you think we have been influenced with similar styles to ours?

'It reminds me of other Scissor Sisters videos'



4. Do you think our genre fitted well with our song or would you ave preffered to have a more illustrative story line to the song?
Yes- 39
No-1




5. If no How could we improve our style of video

-'I personally like video's with a story line or something to follow with the music'
-'You could have tried more to mix a storyline with surrealism, such as Katy Perrys California Girls'



6. Do you like the use of costumes and do you think they fit in with the themes of the video?
Yes- 40



7. Do you think the editing fits with the video and how could it be improved?

-'Without the editing the whole video would be very dull'
-'The editing is done very well and It doesn't need improving in anyway'
-'I especially like the moving and flashing backgrounds, it is very effective'
-'It fits with the style of video'
-'To make the video better I would improve continuality'
-'I like the editing'
-'You could make it flow more and the shots fit together'

8. Once you have viewed the video with the song what would you think of if you heard the song on the radio?

-'The megaphones and flashing backgrounds'
-'Slow walkers in line at the end'
-'megaphones woo woo'
-'body popping in time to the music'
-'flashing backgrounds'
-'Nightlife'
-'cones'
-'megaphones'
-'slow walks in line'
-'walking with megaphones'


9. How did the music video make you feel?

-'fun, lively and portrayed my feelings afterwards'
-'I want to join in and sing with attitude'
-'Reminded me of my youth'
-'I wanted to sing along even though I didn't know the words'
-'fun'
-'I wanted to dance'
-'It was lively and got my attention'


10. Did you enjoy watching the music video?
Yes-40




11. Would you recommend the music video to a friend?
yes- 36
No-4






12. Overall what score would you give the music video out of 10(being highest)?
7/10- 6
8/10- 8
9/10- 12
10/10- 14